What the Pipeline Spilled / Compare

Operator vs Operator

Put any two operators' ledger pages side by side. Each metric shares one scale across the gutter, so bar length is the comparison, and every card is flagged against the sixteen-operator fleet average - a fixed baseline that does not move with your picks. Numbers are illustrative stand-ins; see the methodology on the main page.

Panel A

Plains All American Pipeline

Crude oil / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 412,000
above fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 720
above fleet avg (418)
Property damage $610M
above fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 2
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 9
at or below fleet avg (15)

Enbridge (Lakehead System)

Crude oil / HQ WI

Net barrels lost 340,000
above fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 430
above fleet avg (418)
Property damage $690M
above fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 1
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 7
at or below fleet avg (15)

Enterprise Products (Crude & NGL)

HVL / NGL / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 318,000
above fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 640
above fleet avg (418)
Property damage $540M
above fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 3
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 14
at or below fleet avg (15)

Energy Transfer / Sunoco Pipeline

Crude oil / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 286,000
above fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 590
above fleet avg (418)
Property damage $505M
above fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 4
above fleet avg (3)
Injuries 11
at or below fleet avg (15)

Marathon Pipe Line

Crude oil / HQ OH

Net barrels lost 224,000
above fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 470
above fleet avg (418)
Property damage $398M
at or below fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 2
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 8
at or below fleet avg (15)

Colonial Pipeline

Refined products / HQ GA

Net barrels lost 206,000
above fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 300
at or below fleet avg (418)
Property damage $455M
above fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 3
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 5
at or below fleet avg (15)

ExxonMobil Pipeline

Crude oil / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 178,000
at or below fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 360
at or below fleet avg (418)
Property damage $405M
at or below fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 1
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 6
at or below fleet avg (15)

Magellan Pipeline

Refined products / HQ OK

Net barrels lost 168,000
at or below fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 510
above fleet avg (418)
Property damage $352M
at or below fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 1
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 6
at or below fleet avg (15)

Kinder Morgan (SFPP & CO2)

Refined products / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 152,000
at or below fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 480
above fleet avg (418)
Property damage $338M
at or below fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 2
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 10
at or below fleet avg (15)

Phillips 66 Pipeline

Refined products / HQ OK

Net barrels lost 141,000
at or below fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 395
at or below fleet avg (418)
Property damage $296M
at or below fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 2
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 7
at or below fleet avg (15)

Chevron Pipe Line

Crude oil / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 133,000
at or below fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 320
at or below fleet avg (418)
Property damage $284M
at or below fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 1
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 5
at or below fleet avg (15)

ONEOK NGL Pipeline

HVL / NGL / HQ OK

Net barrels lost 126,000
at or below fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 300
at or below fleet avg (418)
Property damage $240M
at or below fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 2
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 9
at or below fleet avg (15)

Shell Pipeline

Crude oil / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 121,000
at or below fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 280
at or below fleet avg (418)
Property damage $258M
at or below fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 1
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 4
at or below fleet avg (15)

Buckeye Partners

Refined products / HQ PA

Net barrels lost 118,000
at or below fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 340
at or below fleet avg (418)
Property damage $262M
at or below fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 1
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 8
at or below fleet avg (15)

Pacific Gas & Electric

Gas transmission / HQ CA

Net barrels lost 0
at or below fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 210
at or below fleet avg (418)
Property damage $880M
above fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 10
above fleet avg (3)
Injuries 58
above fleet avg (15)

Atmos Energy

Gas distribution / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 0
at or below fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 340
at or below fleet avg (418)
Property damage $410M
at or below fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 17
above fleet avg (3)
Injuries 71
above fleet avg (15)
Panel B

Plains All American Pipeline

Crude oil / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 412,000
above fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 720
above fleet avg (418)
Property damage $610M
above fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 2
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 9
at or below fleet avg (15)

Enbridge (Lakehead System)

Crude oil / HQ WI

Net barrels lost 340,000
above fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 430
above fleet avg (418)
Property damage $690M
above fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 1
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 7
at or below fleet avg (15)

Enterprise Products (Crude & NGL)

HVL / NGL / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 318,000
above fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 640
above fleet avg (418)
Property damage $540M
above fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 3
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 14
at or below fleet avg (15)

Energy Transfer / Sunoco Pipeline

Crude oil / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 286,000
above fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 590
above fleet avg (418)
Property damage $505M
above fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 4
above fleet avg (3)
Injuries 11
at or below fleet avg (15)

Marathon Pipe Line

Crude oil / HQ OH

Net barrels lost 224,000
above fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 470
above fleet avg (418)
Property damage $398M
at or below fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 2
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 8
at or below fleet avg (15)

Colonial Pipeline

Refined products / HQ GA

Net barrels lost 206,000
above fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 300
at or below fleet avg (418)
Property damage $455M
above fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 3
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 5
at or below fleet avg (15)

ExxonMobil Pipeline

Crude oil / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 178,000
at or below fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 360
at or below fleet avg (418)
Property damage $405M
at or below fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 1
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 6
at or below fleet avg (15)

Magellan Pipeline

Refined products / HQ OK

Net barrels lost 168,000
at or below fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 510
above fleet avg (418)
Property damage $352M
at or below fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 1
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 6
at or below fleet avg (15)

Kinder Morgan (SFPP & CO2)

Refined products / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 152,000
at or below fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 480
above fleet avg (418)
Property damage $338M
at or below fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 2
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 10
at or below fleet avg (15)

Phillips 66 Pipeline

Refined products / HQ OK

Net barrels lost 141,000
at or below fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 395
at or below fleet avg (418)
Property damage $296M
at or below fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 2
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 7
at or below fleet avg (15)

Chevron Pipe Line

Crude oil / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 133,000
at or below fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 320
at or below fleet avg (418)
Property damage $284M
at or below fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 1
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 5
at or below fleet avg (15)

ONEOK NGL Pipeline

HVL / NGL / HQ OK

Net barrels lost 126,000
at or below fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 300
at or below fleet avg (418)
Property damage $240M
at or below fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 2
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 9
at or below fleet avg (15)

Shell Pipeline

Crude oil / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 121,000
at or below fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 280
at or below fleet avg (418)
Property damage $258M
at or below fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 1
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 4
at or below fleet avg (15)

Buckeye Partners

Refined products / HQ PA

Net barrels lost 118,000
at or below fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 340
at or below fleet avg (418)
Property damage $262M
at or below fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 1
at or below fleet avg (3)
Injuries 8
at or below fleet avg (15)

Pacific Gas & Electric

Gas transmission / HQ CA

Net barrels lost 0
at or below fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 210
at or below fleet avg (418)
Property damage $880M
above fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 10
above fleet avg (3)
Injuries 58
above fleet avg (15)

Atmos Energy

Gas distribution / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 0
at or below fleet avg (182,688)
Significant incidents 340
at or below fleet avg (418)
Property damage $410M
at or below fleet avg ($433M)
Deaths 17
above fleet avg (3)
Injuries 71
above fleet avg (15)