What the Pipeline Spilled / Compare

Operator vs Operator

Put any two operators' ledger pages side by side. Each metric shares one scale across the gutter, so bar length is the comparison, and every card is flagged against the sixteen-operator fleet average - a fixed baseline that does not move with your picks. Figures are PHMSA flagged-file totals, 2010-2025; see the methodology on the main page.

Panel A

ENTERPRISE PRODUCTS OPERATING LLCENTERPRISE CRUDE PIPELINE LLCSUNOCO PIPELINE L.P.PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC COPLAINS PIPELINE, L.P.ENERGY TRANSFER COMPANYCOLONIAL PIPELINE COMAGELLAN PIPELINE COMPANY, LPBUCKEYE PARTNERS, LPMARATHON PIPE LINE LLCONEOK NGL PIPELINE, LLCSOUTHERN CALIFORNIA GAS COPHILLIPS 66 PIPELINE LLCCONSUMERS ENERGY COKINDER MORGAN LIQUID TERMINALS, LLCSHELL PIPELINE CO., L.P.

ENTERPRISE PRODUCTS OPERATING LLC

HVL / NGL / HQ MO

Net barrels lost 175,068

above fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 236

above fleet avg (86)

Property damage $169M

above fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 6

above fleet avg (2)

Injuries 13

above fleet avg (8)

ENTERPRISE CRUDE PIPELINE LLC

Crude oil / HQ OK

Net barrels lost 14,137

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 116

above fleet avg (86)

Property damage $96M

at or below fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 0

at or below fleet avg (2)

Injuries 2

at or below fleet avg (8)

SUNOCO PIPELINE L.P.

Crude oil / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 13,299

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 88

above fleet avg (86)

Property damage $107M

at or below fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 0

at or below fleet avg (2)

Injuries 0

at or below fleet avg (8)

PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC CO

Gas distribution / HQ CA

Net barrels lost 0

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 87

above fleet avg (86)

Property damage $840M

above fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 12

above fleet avg (2)

Injuries 77

above fleet avg (8)

PLAINS PIPELINE, L.P.

Crude oil / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 4,158

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 86

above fleet avg (86)

Property damage $222M

above fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 0

at or below fleet avg (2)

Injuries 0

at or below fleet avg (8)

ENERGY TRANSFER COMPANY

HVL / NGL / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 62,238

above fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 85

at or below fleet avg (86)

Property damage $47M

at or below fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 1

at or below fleet avg (2)

Injuries 3

at or below fleet avg (8)

COLONIAL PIPELINE CO

Refined products / HQ VA

Net barrels lost 25,956

above fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 81

at or below fleet avg (86)

Property damage $337M

above fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 2

above fleet avg (2)

Injuries 4

at or below fleet avg (8)

MAGELLAN PIPELINE COMPANY, LP

Refined products / HQ IA

Net barrels lost 6,850

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 80

at or below fleet avg (86)

Property damage $60M

at or below fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 0

at or below fleet avg (2)

Injuries 0

at or below fleet avg (8)

BUCKEYE PARTNERS, LP

Refined products / HQ IL

Net barrels lost 1,747

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 76

at or below fleet avg (86)

Property damage $89M

at or below fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 0

at or below fleet avg (2)

Injuries 0

at or below fleet avg (8)

MARATHON PIPE LINE LLC

Crude oil / HQ MI

Net barrels lost 8,280

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 75

at or below fleet avg (86)

Property damage $141M

at or below fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 0

at or below fleet avg (2)

Injuries 0

at or below fleet avg (8)

ONEOK NGL PIPELINE, LLC

Refined products / HQ IL

Net barrels lost 18,762

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 69

at or below fleet avg (86)

Property damage $6M

at or below fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 0

at or below fleet avg (2)

Injuries 2

at or below fleet avg (8)

SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA GAS CO

Gas distribution / HQ CA

Net barrels lost 0

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 64

at or below fleet avg (86)

Property damage $96M

at or below fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 4

above fleet avg (2)

Injuries 16

above fleet avg (8)

PHILLIPS 66 PIPELINE LLC

HVL / NGL / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 17,955

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 60

at or below fleet avg (86)

Property damage $41M

at or below fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 1

at or below fleet avg (2)

Injuries 1

at or below fleet avg (8)

CONSUMERS ENERGY CO

Gas distribution / HQ MI

Net barrels lost 0

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 60

at or below fleet avg (86)

Property damage $80M

at or below fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 5

above fleet avg (2)

Injuries 9

above fleet avg (8)

KINDER MORGAN LIQUID TERMINALS, LLC

Refined products / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 7,463

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 54

at or below fleet avg (86)

Property damage $36M

at or below fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 0

at or below fleet avg (2)

Injuries 0

at or below fleet avg (8)

SHELL PIPELINE CO., L.P.

Crude oil / HQ LA

Net barrels lost 2,006

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 53

at or below fleet avg (86)

Property damage $91M

at or below fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 0

at or below fleet avg (2)

Injuries 0

at or below fleet avg (8)

Panel B

ENTERPRISE PRODUCTS OPERATING LLC

HVL / NGL / HQ MO

Net barrels lost 175,068

above fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 236

above fleet avg (86)

Property damage $169M

above fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 6

above fleet avg (2)

Injuries 13

above fleet avg (8)

ENTERPRISE CRUDE PIPELINE LLC

Crude oil / HQ OK

Net barrels lost 14,137

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 116

above fleet avg (86)

Property damage $96M

at or below fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 0

at or below fleet avg (2)

Injuries 2

at or below fleet avg (8)

SUNOCO PIPELINE L.P.

Crude oil / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 13,299

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 88

above fleet avg (86)

Property damage $107M

at or below fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 0

at or below fleet avg (2)

Injuries 0

at or below fleet avg (8)

PACIFIC GAS & ELECTRIC CO

Gas distribution / HQ CA

Net barrels lost 0

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 87

above fleet avg (86)

Property damage $840M

above fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 12

above fleet avg (2)

Injuries 77

above fleet avg (8)

PLAINS PIPELINE, L.P.

Crude oil / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 4,158

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 86

above fleet avg (86)

Property damage $222M

above fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 0

at or below fleet avg (2)

Injuries 0

at or below fleet avg (8)

ENERGY TRANSFER COMPANY

HVL / NGL / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 62,238

above fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 85

at or below fleet avg (86)

Property damage $47M

at or below fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 1

at or below fleet avg (2)

Injuries 3

at or below fleet avg (8)

COLONIAL PIPELINE CO

Refined products / HQ VA

Net barrels lost 25,956

above fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 81

at or below fleet avg (86)

Property damage $337M

above fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 2

above fleet avg (2)

Injuries 4

at or below fleet avg (8)

MAGELLAN PIPELINE COMPANY, LP

Refined products / HQ IA

Net barrels lost 6,850

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 80

at or below fleet avg (86)

Property damage $60M

at or below fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 0

at or below fleet avg (2)

Injuries 0

at or below fleet avg (8)

BUCKEYE PARTNERS, LP

Refined products / HQ IL

Net barrels lost 1,747

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 76

at or below fleet avg (86)

Property damage $89M

at or below fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 0

at or below fleet avg (2)

Injuries 0

at or below fleet avg (8)

MARATHON PIPE LINE LLC

Crude oil / HQ MI

Net barrels lost 8,280

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 75

at or below fleet avg (86)

Property damage $141M

at or below fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 0

at or below fleet avg (2)

Injuries 0

at or below fleet avg (8)

ONEOK NGL PIPELINE, LLC

Refined products / HQ IL

Net barrels lost 18,762

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 69

at or below fleet avg (86)

Property damage $6M

at or below fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 0

at or below fleet avg (2)

Injuries 2

at or below fleet avg (8)

SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA GAS CO

Gas distribution / HQ CA

Net barrels lost 0

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 64

at or below fleet avg (86)

Property damage $96M

at or below fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 4

above fleet avg (2)

Injuries 16

above fleet avg (8)

PHILLIPS 66 PIPELINE LLC

HVL / NGL / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 17,955

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 60

at or below fleet avg (86)

Property damage $41M

at or below fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 1

at or below fleet avg (2)

Injuries 1

at or below fleet avg (8)

CONSUMERS ENERGY CO

Gas distribution / HQ MI

Net barrels lost 0

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 60

at or below fleet avg (86)

Property damage $80M

at or below fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 5

above fleet avg (2)

Injuries 9

above fleet avg (8)

KINDER MORGAN LIQUID TERMINALS, LLC

Refined products / HQ TX

Net barrels lost 7,463

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 54

at or below fleet avg (86)

Property damage $36M

at or below fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 0

at or below fleet avg (2)

Injuries 0

at or below fleet avg (8)

SHELL PIPELINE CO., L.P.

Crude oil / HQ LA

Net barrels lost 2,006

at or below fleet avg (22,370)

Significant incidents 53

at or below fleet avg (86)

Property damage $91M

at or below fleet avg ($154M)

Deaths 0

at or below fleet avg (2)

Injuries 0

at or below fleet avg (8)